The Intranet built for Google Workspace
How to Audit Your Google Sites Intranet
No UX Team Required
Sherwin Steel
Technology Consultant, Steegle.One
You’ve invested heavily in your internal communications, migrating documents, and organizing Google Drive folders. Yet, your digital workplace is a ghost town. When employees need the updated remote work policy, they search the intranet, find three conflicting drafts from 2021, give up, and send a Slack message to HR instead.
This is the hidden cost of a broken digital workplace: wasted time, overwhelmed support teams, and zero employee trust. You might think you need a massive, expensive software migration to fix this, but you don't. You simply need to diagnose the structural friction in your current setup and fix the foundation before you lose your team's engagement entirely.
What is an Intranet Usability Review?
An intranet usability review, or heuristic evaluation, is a structured expert walkthrough of your internal digital workplace. Evaluators use established usability principles to identify friction points, confusing navigation, and broken workflows without requiring expensive user testing or a dedicated UX team.
The Hidden Cost of Bad Intranet UX (And Why Analytics Lie)
Most intranet managers rely entirely on page view analytics to measure success. But analytics are fundamentally flawed for this purpose: they tell you what employees are visiting, but they never tell you why an employee gave up on a page or couldn't find an onboarding checklist. If it takes a manager five clicks and two separate logins just to find a standard disciplinary procedure, your intranet has a usability crisis that page views will never reveal.
Don't wait for your annual employee survey to find out your intranet is failing. Treat an influx of routine "where do I find this?" emails to HR and IT as your primary indicator that your navigation architecture is fundamentally broken.
The 4 Core Pillars of a Digital Workplace Health Check
If you are using Google Workspace, you don't need to hire a $50,000 external consultancy to evaluate your digital workplace. According to insights on running a 5-minute intranet health check, you can assess your current setup against four core heuristic pillars.
First, consider Findability.
IT teams often rely too heavily on the search bar, but if a new hire doesn't know the exact internal name for an "IT Hardware Request Form," search won't help them.
Next is Credibility.
For HR teams, out-of-date information is toxic; if an employee finds a superseded parental leave policy, they will instantly assume the entire intranet is non-compliant and default to asking colleagues instead.
Next, assemble a small, cross-functional evaluation team of two to four people. Do not just use the team that built the intranet. Bring in an IT administrator, an internal comms manager, and crucially, a relatively new employee who represents a fresh, unbiased perspective. Brief the team on your core heuristics and ask them to navigate the intranet using realistic, task-based scenarios, such as "Find out who my HR Business Partner is" or "Submit an IT access request".
As your evaluators walk through these tasks independently, have them document every single friction point and assign a severity rating. Once everyone has completed their solo walkthrough, bring the team together for a one-hour debrief to consolidate findings, remove duplicates, and agree on a final, prioritized improvement list.
Third is Usability
which operations teams must fiercely protect. If an employee has to open a folder, find a document, click an external link, and sign into a secondary system just to book time off, the friction destroys the value of the tool.
Finally, evaluate Desirability.
Internal communications teams struggle when an intranet looks like a dry, static filing cabinet rather than a modern, branded, and consumer-grade hub that reflects company culture.
Table 1: Signs of a Failing vs. Healthy Intranet
| UX Pillar | Failing Intranet Symptom | Healthy Intranet Experience |
|---|---|---|
| Findability | Employees must memorize exact document titles to use search. | Logical navigation guides employees without search. |
| Credibility | Multiple drafts of the same policy exist; no clear owner. | A single source of truth with clear "last updated" tags. |
| Usability | Tasks take 4+ clicks across multiple disconnected systems. | Core tasks and forms are embedded directly in the portal. |
| Desirability | Looks like a spreadsheet; visually unengaging. | Branded, consumer-grade design that celebrates culture. |
How to Run Your Own Intranet Heuristic Evaluation (Step-by-Step)
To run your own usability review, you need to structure your approach so it yields data, not just opinions. Start by defining your scope. A full evaluation of every single page is unwieldy and unnecessary; instead, limit your focus to the top three most-used sections, such as the homepage, the HR portal, and the IT self-service section.
| Score | Severity Level | Action Required |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cosmetic | Minor issue; fix only if time permits. |
| 2 | Minor | Causes some friction; fix in the next update. |
| 3 | Major | Causes significant difficulty; prioritize immediately. |
| 4 | Critical | Prevents task completion; drop everything and fix. |
Table 2: Usability Issue Severity Scoring
Moving from Diagnosis to Action in Google Workspace
Once you compile your findings, you will likely see a split between "quick wins" and "structural changes". Quick wins—like fixing a broken link, updating a confusing page title, or adding a confirmation message to a Google Form—can be resolved in minutes natively within Google Sites. However, structural changes—like completely rethinking your navigation hierarchy or rebuilding a fragmented document library—require a deeper solution.
When faced with massive structural failures, many organizations mistakenly assume they must abandon Google Workspace and buy an expensive third-party platform. But according to digital workplace experts, this introduces unnecessary vendor bloat and complex migrations. Instead, you should look to pre-architected intranet frameworks built explicitly for your ecosystem.
Solutions like Steegle.One are designed by UX experts to pass these heuristic tests out-of-the-box. They provide intuitive global navigation, centralize documents through governed Google Drive integrations (Steegle Share), and embed employee directories (Steegle People) natively within your existing Google tenant. By leveraging a native platform, you fix your structural UX problems instantly without sacrificing security or forcing employees to learn a new system.
Never evaluate an intranet by simply clicking through pages randomly. Always use realistic, scenario-based tasks (e.g., "Find the onboarding checklist for a new starter") to surface the exact heuristic violations that broad browsing misses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Steegle.One for Google Workspace
-
No. While a UX expert helps, HR, IT, or internal comms professionals can successfully run it using established usability principles. Two or three cross-functional reviewers from different departments will provide excellent, actionable insights without requiring any formal UX design training.
-
Expect one to two hours per reviewer for the walkthrough, plus an additional hour for debriefing and consolidation. A focused evaluation of your core intranet sections typically takes just one working day to complete for a small, dedicated evaluation team.
-
Employee surveys measure general satisfaction and subjective feelings. A heuristic evaluation objectively diagnoses specific structural failures—like confusing HR jargon or buried request forms—explaining precisely why your employees are frustrated and exactly where the digital workplace experience breaks down.
-
You should actively check for inconsistent page templates, missing breadcrumb navigation, poorly rendered embedded Drive documents, unconfigured form confirmations, and search results that surface outdated content because old pages were never properly archived by the internal communications team.
-
Always start with four critical findings that completely prevent task completion. Next, tackle high-frequency tasks, like a broken leave request form, before dedicating resources to fixing a minor cosmetic issue on a rarely visited, low-priority intranet page.
-
You should run an evaluation annually, or immediately following any major structural changes, platform migrations, or homepage redesigns. Pair this assessment with a routine content audit for a highly comprehensive, data-driven health check of your entire digital workplace.
Take Action on Your Employee Experience
Stop watching your employees struggle with a broken digital workplace. If your current Google Workspace intranet is failing its usability review, you don't need a massive, expensive software migration to fix it.
Steegle.One provides a pre-architected, highly governed native solution that brings knowledge, people, and tools into one unified hub. Built explicitly for Google Workspace, it instantly resolves structural friction, centralizes your documents, and gives your team a single source of truth—without forcing them to learn a new system.
Discover the benefit of working together in an intuitive new digital home. Speak to Steegle today to see it in action.
#GoogleSites #IntranetAudit #InternalComms #DigitalWorkplace #GoogleWorkspace #FixYourIntranet #GoogleWorkspaceTips #DigitalWorkplaceUX #EmployeeExperience
Related Insights